Shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves claims that whichever party wins the election, it will inherit the worst set of economic circumstances since World War Two.
Clearly, some governments in recent decades have faced big economic challenges.
Margaret Thatcher came to power in 1979 at the time of an oil crisis and rapidly-rising prices and the coalition government of 2010 followed a global financial crisis.
But Ms Reeves told the BBC that the current situation was “a dire inheritance” as she laid out the measures she was basing the claim upon.
We have had a look at the evidence for each of them.
Ms Reeves said: “If you look at debt as a share of our economy that’s the highest since 1951.”
Actually, the Office for National Statistics, which compiles the figures, says: “Net debt as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is currently at levels last seen in the early 1960s.”
Ethan Ilzetzki, from the London School of Economics, described the current level of debt as being “high but nowhere close to where it was in the 1950s”.
And on the overall claim about the worst conditions since World War Two, he said: “I struggle to find a metric that would make that statement correct”.
The shadow chancellor said: “The tax burden is the highest for 70 years.”
The tax level, measured by how much of the country’s economic output (measured by GDP) is raised in tax revenues, is estimated to be just above 36% this year.
This is high historically. It has only been higher last year and in the first two years on record, 1948 and 1949, a time when the UK was recovering from the war and the NHS was founded.
Taxation is projected to rise to 37.1% in the next five years which would be the highest level on record.
“The economy is currently in recession,” Ms Reeves pointed out.
GDP has been relatively flat over the past two years and the UK went into recession because the economy shrank in the last two quarters of 2023.
However, this recession is not “the worst” since World War Two.
There were deeper ones during the mid-70s, early-80s and the 2008 Financial Crisis that all resulted in shrinkages in the economy for two years in a row.
While it is rare for a country to be in recession during the run-up to an election, if that happens it would not be the first time.
Both the 2010 and the 1992 elections, for example, happened right after years when the UK was in recession.
Stephen Millard, from the National Institute for Economic and Social Research think tank, pointed to the recession at the time of the February 1974 election in which the economy contracted 3.7% while inflation was over 10%.
“These numbers suggest to me that the incoming Labour government in 1974 inherited an economy in worse shape than currently,” he said.
“This will be the first Parliament on record where living standards have gone backwards not forwards,” the shadow chancellor said.
The change to living standards is best reflected in households’ real disposable income (RHDI) per person, which fell by 2.2% in 2022-23 – the biggest drop since records began in 1955.
It is projected to rise by 0.8% in 2023-24.
Nevertheless, living standards are obviously considerably better than they were in the 1940s, with current households’ disposable income more than four times higher than after World War Two.
There are other indicators that the shadow chancellor could have looked at that show a different picture.
Inflation is at 4%, which is double the 2% target, but much lower than some previous governments have had to deal with.
The rate of unemployment is at a relatively low level although there is concern about the number of people who have withdrawn from the labour market.
And the volume of retail sales is below pre-pandemic levels but is still higher than it was at any point prior to 2018.
What do you want BBC Verify to investigate?
Add Comment